More than 75 years after Richard Asher’s classic article in The Lancet, the behaviors he identified in medical practice take on a new meaning in light of environmental, social and governance impacts in healthcare.
In 1949, British physician Richard Asher published the provocative article The Seven Sins of Medicine in The Lancet. In it, he identified seven problematic behaviors that, at the time, harmed patients and medical practice itself.
More than 75 years later, rereading the article from an ESG perspective, I propose a new interpretation of these criticisms: many of the behaviors Asher pointed out can also be associated with environmental, social and governance impacts in healthcare.
The seven sins of medicine – Richard Asher, 1949
- Obscurity: communicating in a confusing, complicated or unclear way.
- Cruelty: investigations and interventions that cause unnecessary suffering.
- Bad manners: treating patients and colleagues without respect, courtesy and consideration.
- Over-specialization: seeing only one part or the disease, losing sight of the patient as a whole.
- Love of the rare: looking for unusual diagnoses when simple explanations are more likely.
- Common stupidity: acting automatically, following routines and protocols without critical reflection.
- Sloth: not devoting the necessary effort to the clinical history, reasoning and decision-making.
A reinterpretation from an ESG perspective
Environmental
Unnecessary tests, procedures and treatments consume materials, medicines and energy. They also generate waste and greenhouse gas emissions.
Avoiding what adds no value for the patient also means reducing environmental impacts.
Social
Inadequate communication, fragmented care and interventions without sufficient benefit directly affect:
- safety
- dignity
- autonomy
- patient experience
Sustainability also means ensuring person-centered care.
Governance
Automatic behaviors, lack of reflection and practices without evidence raise questions about:
- protocols
- scientific evidence
- risk management
- quality of care
- clinical governance
Better decisions depend on strong governance systems.
Sustainability in healthcare is not only about managing energy, water, waste or emissions. It also lies in the thousands of clinical decisions made every day.
Promoting safe, evidence-based, high-value care that uses resources responsibly is the path toward more sustainable healthcare.

