Sustainable hospitals: do their financial investments also follow ESG criteria?

Estetoscópio sobre pasta com moedas e cédulas, em ambiente hospitalar

Experiences in Canada and the United States raise the question of consistency between hospitals’ sustainability commitments and where they put their financial resources.

Hospitals invest in energy efficiency, emissions reduction, waste management, social responsibility and corporate governance.

But the sustainability of these institutions also depends on a less visible decision: where they invest their money.

The sectors financed by these investments may have effects on the environment and health that conflict with the commitments made by the organizations themselves. A Canadian project and a US study help to understand this relationship and raise a question for the Brazilian sector: do investment policies keep pace with hospitals’ ESG agenda?

What the investments show

The US study analyzed the pension funds of four large hospital systems in the United States: Kaiser Permanente, Mayo Clinic, HCA Healthcare and Ascension.

The survey identified around US$ 774 million invested directly in companies that produce oil, coal and natural gas. When other segments linked to fossil fuels and forms of financial exposure were included, such as suppliers, transporters, energy utilities and indirect investments, the amount reached approximately US$ 4.59 billion.

The data correspond to financial positions in December 2021 and include estimates of exposure through diversified funds. It is therefore a snapshot of that period, which does not allow conclusions about the current composition of the portfolios.

The authors’ criticism is clear: institutions that recognize climate change as a threat to health kept resources invested in activities that contribute to making it worse.

Beyond operations

The Canadian project brings another perspective to the debate: how the capital managed by the healthcare sector can contribute to a more sustainable economy.

The sustainability discussion tends to focus on hospital operations, while financial investments receive less attention. Knowing where these resources go is essential to assess whether investments are also aligned with the institution’s environmental and social commitments.

Do no harm: a principle for money too?

The US report links investment decisions to the medical principle of doing no harm. Its authors argue that hospitals’ responsibility in the face of climate change should also extend to financial management.

For this reason, they recommend that institutions review their exposure to fossil fuels and adopt divestment strategies. In the authors’ view, keeping resources in these activities contradicts the mission of protecting health.

This discussion requires taking into account each institution’s conditions, its fiduciary obligations and the requirements of security, liquidity and profitability. The point is to bring the risks and impacts of the sectors receiving the resources into the analysis.

And in Brazil?

The advance of the ESG agenda in Brazilian healthcare opens space to examine this issue. If hospitals already assess the impacts of their operations and suppliers, it is worth asking how sustainability criteria play a role in investment decisions.

Do boards and finance committees know how portfolios are exposed to different economic sectors? Do they consider climate risks? Do investment policies set ESG criteria? Do sustainability reports explain how these criteria are applied?

The international experiences do not allow us to conclude that Brazilian hospitals hold investments that are incompatible with their commitments. They do, however, offer a reason to look more closely at this part of management.

“For institutions whose mission is to care for health, where the money goes also deserves to be part of the sustainability conversation.”